Notesale: Turn your study into money

Document Preview

Extracts from the notes are below, to see the PDF you'll receive please use the links above

---

European Union Withdrawal Act 2018
Prime Minister Theresa May has announced that her government will introduce a "major
withdrawal bill" to allow the UK to leave the European Union (EU)
...
" It was
introduced with 19 clauses and eight timetables, but by the time it received Royal Assent almost
a year later, on June 26, 2018, it had grown by 63% and now has 25 sections and nine
timetables1
...
This happens in two ways: Some types of EU law (including treaty obligations and
regulations) directly affect the UK legal system without requiring the UK Parliament to pass
additional legislation
...
Other types of EU law (including directives and
decisions) can be used in the UK through primary law (the Act of Parliament) or, more generally,
through secondary law
...
Secondly, Put all EU laws in UK books
...
This means that the laws and regulations introduced
during the past 40 years when the UK was a member of the EU will continue to apply after
Brexit
...

Last but not least, it provides ministers the authority to create supplemental laws
...
In several EU laws, for
example, it is stated that the UK will no longer participate in EU institutions or that the law itself
would no longer be a part of the UK legal system
...
The Act grants ministers
what are known as "Henry VIII powers" to amend both primary and secondary legislations using
statutory instruments, which can become law more quickly because Parliament does not as
closely regulate them4
...
This caused
controversy throughout Bill's passage, and numerous amendments proposed by backbench MPs
and peers sought to restrict the purposes for which these powers could be used and how they
would be reviewed6
...
This legislation concerns two highlighted points; in the first instance, ensuring that the
UK side of the withdrawal agreement is confirmed and preparing the way for the UK to exit the
EU on January 31, 2020, when the EU has ratified the deal (and signed by the parties)
...
Even though the UK will no longer be an EU member after January 31,
2020, it will continue to be a part of the EU Customs Union and Single Market throughout this
time, and the great majority of EU legislation and rulings will still be in effect
...
After that, the EU Council will have to formally decide whether to approve the
Withdrawal Agreement, which all parties must also sign
...
m
...
However, as was already mentioned, there won't be much change
immediately because of the transition phase10
...
The WAB
does nothing to reduce the likelihood that undesirable outcomes, like those mentioned above,
will occur
...
Compared to the 2018
Act, the new Bill has 19 delegated powers
...

The revised Bill also preserves the authority for urgent cases, but it extends it such that it won't
expire until two years after the transition period is over
...


7

European Union Withdrawal (Agreement) Act 2020
Treaty on European Union Section 50(2)
9
Travers
...


The Application of EU Law Generally

On January 31, 2020, or "exit day," the UK left the EU
...
After that, the EU Treaties, EU
Free Movement Rights, and the general principles of EU law will cease to apply in the UK
...
For example, the European Communities Act of
1972 was repealed (with effect from December 31, 2020) by the EU Withdrawal Act (as
amended) ("ECA 1972"13)
...
The Act contains provisions that convert directly applicable
EU laws that are in effect on IP completion day (as opposed to exit day) and would otherwise
expire at the end of the transition period into UK domestic law
...
Although the general use of secondary legislation to facilitate the necessary
transposition of EU law into domestic law has drawn criticism, this strategy is meant to assure
the continuation of a functioning statute book in the areas covered by EU law
...
The
rule also expressly excludes the possibility of disapplying a law or declaring illegal behavior
based on incompatibility with the general principles of EU law after the end of the transitional
period
...
Moreover, the Act also allows new appeals after the end of the transitional
period for non-compliance with the general principles of Union law, provided that they are
introduced within three years of the end of the transitional period, refer to past facts, and do not
disappear, directly or indirectly any law or the other rule of law
...
However, the EU provided that this does not apply to
proceedings commenced before the end of the transition period, with the exception that if it
concerns anything before or during the transition period, such proceedings may be started after
the end of the if they relate to anything which occurred before or during the transition period14
...
Similarly,
Section 29 of the European Union (Future Relationship) Act 2020 modifies all domestic laws to
conform with the UK-EU Trade and Cooperation Agreement
...
This, however, has no
bearing on legal actions that were started before or during the transition period
...
Consequently17, Brexit
unavoidably influenced the legislation resulting from and linked to Article 50 TEU18
...
However,
the legal ambiguity of how the UK courts will interpret these rules has raised serious concerns
...
" However, in practice, all UK courts are likely to be highly affected by
non-binding post-Brexit EU case law when they read the same legislation19
...
Due to the
fact that the ECHR is not a European Union legislation but instead falls within the domain of the
Council of European, which is an entirely separated Institution
...
It is an international agreement created within the Council of Europe, an intergovernmental
organization not a part of the EU
...
The
European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) in Strasbourg upholds the ECHR, which was created
to preserve human rights and fundamental freedoms throughout Europe
...
As a result, the ECtHR's rulings are not binding on the EU20
...
A separate
EU Charter of Fundamental Rights, which has the legal status of a treaty and safeguards rights
comparable to those protected by the ECHR, also binds the EU
...

Additionally, the European Court of Justice provides the ECHR with's principles extra weight
when determining decisions
...


Furthermore, since the European Patent Convention 23is not a component of the EU machinery,
the UK will continue to participate in the system
...


ii
...


General principles of European law are unwritten legislation that is used and applied to the
interpretation of EU law
...
As a result, we can close legal gaps and increase legal consistency
...
For example, the EU Treaty allows EU courts to
apply general principles of state law in determining the civil liability of the EU itself
...
25

The "Supremacy principles" is a concept developed by the Court of Justice of the European
Union (CJEU) in the early days of what would become the European Union
...
Under the EUWA26, the importance of EU law continued after the withdrawal date
(January 31, 2020, 11 pm) as far as the rest of the interpretation of EU law is concerned
...
Governments are therefore considering what kind of relationship between these
two legal systems is most appropriate given the need to promote legal certainty
...
Extra court powers may also be used for interpretation
in cases of dispute27
...
However, Article 5(2) states that EU
supremacy will continue to apply after the withdrawal date to the extent that it relates to the
interpretation or non-application of laws enacted or enacted before the withdrawal date
...
However, the Constitutional Commission (2008)30 considers the concept of
hegemony problematic in this context
...
Therefore, he cannot apply the supremacy of EU law to the
EU law being held, as it is not EU law in the strict sense of the word
...


Article 1 of the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 201833 repeals the European Community Law
197234 on the withdrawal date
...
Will be
...
A decision of the European Union
Council of April 10, 2019, extended his time until Brexit to October 31, 2019, in accordance
with Article 50(3) TEU35
...
The UK has a new Prime Minister who has decided to
step down on October 31, but this is not yet certain36
...
Congress makes legislation in many areas
...
The task of transposing EU
law into national law has been described as a "legal obligation of a unique and unprecedented
nature and scale" (Constitutional Committee 2018)38
...
Therefore, it is suitable to address the question of hegemony, as the
Withdrawal Act will play a role in the constitutional landscape after Britain leaves the EU40
...
These principles are defined in Section 6
(7) as follows: the general principles of EU law applicable to EU law immediately prior to the IP
Transaction Date; and (a) in relation to those to which Articles 2, 3, or 4 apply; To the extent not
via Schedule 1 (as these policies may be amended from time to time by or under this or other
domestic law)42
...
It was also deeply involved in the entire process and sought to steer
it to carry out its mission of leading the Coalition in its future development
...
These
can be boiled down to some basic legal and political principles
...
In the
second instance, the UK intended to leave but still had an obligation to cooperate in good faith
under Article 4(3) of the TEU43
...


The UK entered the negotiations with the expectation of retaining access to the single market and
all other rights and entitlements of EU membership while controlling its own borders and
withdrawing from the legal policy
...
However, the EU decided not to allow this, so
negotiations began on the point of not conceding the UK as a third country
...


41

European Union Withdrawal Act Section 6
European Union Withdrawal Act Section 6(7)
43
Treaty of European Union Article 4(3)
44
The Legal Position Surrounding Brexit Lecture Cast Unit 9
42

iii
...

The transition period (known as the implementation period) ended on December 31, 2020
...
The transition period is
necessary due to the fact to give the European Union and the United Kingdom a particular space
after the new negotiations takes their place fully
...
A statute can be a primary law or a
secondary law
...

Lord Judge Roger, in the Mucelli v
...
In interpreting them, like Sir Neuberger, ignore explanations that indicate their
meaning
...
No one but the
government knows who designed or modified them or what they were designed on
...
The focus must be on the
language of the Regulation itself
...

From the point of view of EU law, it is highly doubtful that the doctrine of EU supremacy and
indirect effect is based solely on EU case law
...
However, as already
noted, the ECJ has repeatedly cited (different) treaty articles to justify these EU doctrines,
stressing that they are "specific to the treaty system" and is an implicit treaty obligation
...

Furthermore, the eighth category of EU law is the internal market, which continues to apply to
the UK under the Ireland/Northern Ireland Protocol
...
Government
48
Extradition Act of 2003 Section 24(6) and section 104(3)
49
UK Withdrawal from the EU: Supremacy, Indirect Effect and Retained EU Law
46

and Annex 4 of the Protocol); State aid (Article 10 and Annex 5 of the Protocol)
...
It shall give them the authority
to do so
...
In this article, we have examined the configuration aspects of the
EUWA system
...

This analysis is based on an assessment of the EU constitutional doctrines and their
domestication within the framework of the EUWA
...
As a result, the possibility of deviating from
the relevant EU standards held in the future is legally more restricted than previously envisioned
...
It will not work—trade agreements with the EU
...
Whatever the general public might have wanted, the question
underlying Britain's exit - how far to deviate from or comply with the standards set out in the EU
- will be a hot topic for years to come
...
Smith - European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Act 2020
State Watch - European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Act 2020
UK Constitutional Association
The European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018 as Amended by The European Union (Withdrawal
Agreement) Act 2020
European Union Withdrawal (Agreement) Act 2020 Section 7(a)
European Union (Future Relationship) Act 2020 Section 29
Brexit: International and European Union Legal Frameworks Affected and Unaffected
Out/Law – Retained EU Law in The UK after Brexit
Sonia Morano-Foadi and Jen Neller, Law of The European Union (13th Edition, Pearson 2020)
Chapter Three
Treaty on the European Union Article 6(3)
European Patent Convention
General Principles of European Union
The Brexit Freedoms Bill and Changing Retained EU Law
European Union Withdrawal Act 2018 Article 5(1)
European Union Withdrawal Act 2018 Article 5(2)
Constitutional Commission (2008)
Supremacy of European Union Law and Brexit
Elliot and Tierney 2019
European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018 Article 1
Treaty of European Union Article 50(3)
Lord Callanan, 2018
Constitutional Committee 2018
Miller v Secretary [2017] UKSC 5
European Union Withdrawal Act Section 6
European Union Withdrawal Act Section 6(7)
Treaty of European Union Article 4(3)
The Legal Position Surrounding Brexit Lecture Cast Unit 9
Brexit: What is The Transition Period?
Mucelli v

---